Team:Tokyo Tech/Experiment/Crosstalk Circumvention Assay

From 2013.igem.org

(Difference between revisions)
Line 3: Line 3:
<div class="box">
<div class="box">
-
<h1>crosstalk circumvention assay
+
<h1>Crosstalk Circumvention Assay
</h1>
</h1>
-
<h3>Introduction  
+
<h3>1. Introduction
</h3>
</h3>
<h2>
<h2>
-
<p>Our purpose is to check whether the hybrid promoter Plux/tet would be repressed or not when C12-LasR complex and protein TetR are co-existed.(Fig9).  C12-LasR-dependent activation of Plux promoter is known to be problem in synthetic biology and we confirmed this crosstalk activation (Fig)We then compared, for the first time, the amount of crosstalk for Plux/tet hybrid promoter in the presence or absence of the TetR inhibitor aTcThe bindings between TetR protein and TetO sequence on DNA is known to be weakened by aTc.  Tokyo tech 2012 indeed showed that the GFP expression of the cells in which both of C6 and aTc were added was higher than that of the cells in which only C6 was addedSimilarly, if the GFP expression of the cells where we added both of C12 and aTc was higher than that of the cells where we added only C12, it is proved that the crosstalk can be suppressed by TetR.
+
<p>
 +
Of course, if you want to avoid crosstalk, you have to search idea for improvement for crosstalk circumventionHowever, you must make conditions without affecting system wide, or without changing the basis of system in the idea for improvementThis is because "crosstalk circumvention by changing system wide" is same meaning as saying "crosstalk circumvention only in that circuit"For example, when you want to avoid crosstalk in the circuit on the basis of toggle switch system, you should think that it is nonsense to avoid crosstalk by abandoning toggle switch system.  You should think it's nice to avoid crosstalk without abandoning toggle switch system.  In short, I hope crosstalk circumvention system is applicable to various circuits.  Based on this view, we planned the following idea and experimentation.
</p>
</p>
</h2>
</h2>
-
<h3>Construction
+
<h3>2. Summary of the experiment
</h3>
</h3>
-
<h2>
+
<h2><p>Our purpose is to check whether <i>lux/tet</i> hybrid promoter would be repressed or not when 3OC12HSL-LasR complex and protein TetR existed.  We tried to compare the frequency of crosstalk in the presence or absence of the TetR inhibitor aTc.
-
<p>We made a simple crosstalk circumvention system and named it “Crosstalk Circumvention Switch”. (Fig 10)
+
</p>
</p>
-
<p>To construct the circuit in above, we ligated Pcon-RBS-LasR-TT(K553003) and Plux/tet-RBS-GFP-TT(K934025) as the reporter plasmid. We used Pcon-RBS-LuxR-TT-Ptrc-RBS-TetR-TT as the regulator plasmid.
+
<p>We prepared six conditions as follow.<br>
 +
・E-1) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC6HSL induction<br>
 +
・E-2) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC12HSL induction<br>
 +
・E-3) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with DMSO ( no induction)<br>
 +
・F-1) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC6HSL and aTc induction<br>
 +
・F-2) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC12HSL and aTc induction<br>
 +
・F-3) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with DMSO and aTc (no induction)<br>
 +
・Positive control and negative control are similarly operated.<br>
</p>
</p>
</h2>
</h2>
-
<h3>Result
+
<h3>3. Results of Prediction
</h3>
</h3>
<h2>
<h2>
-
<p>In the graph below (Fig11), the level of GFP expression in cells where TetR is active is clearly lower than when TetR is inhibited. This fact could be confirmed in results about C12 and C6. In short, The graph below shows that Plux/tet is repressed by TetR precisely. Furthermore, the graph below shows that there is a great difference between GFP fluorescence intensity of C6+aTc and that of C12+aTc.  This difference was referred in our mathematical modeling.  
+
<p>
 +
aTc weakens the bonding of TetR and <i>tetO</i>.  Therefore, if the GFP expression level of the cells that we added 3OC6HSL and aTc was higher than that of the cells we added only 3OC6HSL, it is proved that <i>lux/tet</i>hybrid promoter is repressed by TetR working. Similarly, if the level of GFP expression of the cells we added 3OC12HSL and aTc was higher than that of the cells we added only 3OC12HSL, it is proved that the crosstalk can be suppressed by TetR and the hybrid promoter.
</p>
</p>
</h2>
</h2>
-
<h3>Discussion
+
<h3>4. Materials and Methods
</h3>
</h3>
-
<h2>
+
<font size="5">
-
<p>Through this assay, we confirmed points below.
+
4-1. Construction
 +
</font>
 +
<h2><p>
 +
On the previous assay we confirmed crosstalk, which 3OC12HSL-LasR complex activates not only <i>las</i> promoter but also <i>lux</i> promoter too (Gray KM et al., 1994).  We came up with idea that crosstalk can be suppressed if <i>lux/tet</i> hybrid promoter is inhibited by protein TetR only when 3OC12HSL-LasR complex is around.  We replaced <i>lux</i> promoter with <i>lux/tet</i>hybrid promoter.  What we have to do in this step is to confirm <i>lux/tet</i> hybrid promoter works correct as a part of the system.  Therefore, we tried to make a simple crosstalk circumvention system (Fig.1).  Protein LuxR, TetR, and LasR are under a constitutive promoter.
 +
</p>
 +
<p>Because of the unexpected restriction enzyme binding site on the regulator plasmid, we had to place protein LuxR and TetR on the regulator plasmid, and <i>lux/tet</i> hybrid promoter, protein GFP and LasR on the reporter plasmid (Fig.2).
 +
</p>
 +
<p>To construct the circuit in above figure (Fig.2), we ligated Pcon-RBS-<i>lasR</i>-TT (K553003) and Plux/tet-RBS-<i>GFP</i>-TT (K934025) as the reporter plasmid.  We used Pcon-RBS-<i>luxR</i>-TT-Ptrc-RBS-<i>tetR</i>-TT as the regulator plasmid.
 +
<br>
 +
・Reporter: pSB6A1-Pcon-<i>lasR</i>-Plux/tet-<i>GFP</i> / Regulator: pSB3K3-Pc-<i>luxR</i>-Ptrc-<i>tetR</i> (JM2.300)...sample<br>
 +
・pSB6A1-Ptet-GFP (JM2.300)…positive control<br>
 +
・pSB6A1-ΔP-GFP (JM2.300)…negative control<br>
</p>
</p>
-
*Plux/tet is precisely repressed by TetR. This shows crosstalk circumvention.
 
-
*An affinity of LuxR-3OC6HSL complex toward Plux/tet is stronger than
 
-
LasR-3OC12HSL complex.
 
-
 
-
 
</h2>
</h2>
-
<h3>mathematical modeling
+
<font size="5">
-
</h3>
+
4-2. Strain
 +
</font>
<h2>
<h2>
-
<p>Modeling of Ninja circuit: Cross-talk circumvention
+
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・JM2.300<br>
 +
</h2>
 +
<br>
 +
<font size="5">
 +
4-3. Protocol
 +
</font>
 +
<h2>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・1. O/N -> FC -> Induction<br>
 +
<p>・1.1 Prepare overnight culture of each cell (GFP posi, GFP nega, sample) at 37°C for 12 h.  (=> O/N)
</p>
</p>
-
<p>(detailed expression is here(link))
+
<p>・1.2 Take 30 microL (from GFP posi, GFP nega, sample) of the overnight culture of inducer cell into LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL+ Kan 30 microg/mL).  (=> Fresh Culture)
</p>
</p>
-
<p>In order to clarify the parameter sensitivities and dynamic characteristics in the of the circumvention of cross-talk between LasR and LuxR, we modeled Ninja circuit by using ODEs. To know how strong the CrossTalk prevention circuit could be, furthermore, we compared with two gene circuits which with or without CrossTalk prevention circuit.  
+
<p>・1.3 Incubate the flesh culture of cells (GFP posi, GFP nega, sample) until the observed OD600 reaches around 0.50.
</p>
</p>
-
<p>Firstly we consider the situation that when E.Civilian comes to cautious state. The following graph shows the switching from cautious state to civilian state which is influenced by C6 came from E.Civilian. And we can know when E.Civilian comes on the time of 300min, CI cautious state will switch to civilian state.
+
<p>・1.4 Take 30 microL each cell suspensions (GFP posi , GFP nega , sample) into<br>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC6HSL (3 microL),<br>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC6HSL (3 microL) + 0.05 microg/mL aTc (3 microL),<br>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC12HSL (3 microL),<br>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mlL+ Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC12HSL (3 μL)+ 0.05 mg/mL aTc (3 microL),<br>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM DMSO (3 microL) and<br>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM DMSO (3 microL) + 0.05 mg/mL aTc (3 microL).<br>
</p>
</p>
-
TetR increases after LacI
+
<p>・1.5 Incubate all samples (6 samples X 6 kinds of culture = 36 samples) for another 4h at 37°C(=> Induction)
-
<p>During the switching from the cautious state to the mimic state, absence of TetR allows activation of Pluxtet hybrid promoter. Repression of TetR production, by CI434, is indeed important in the circuitDuring the mimic state, TetR accumulates to plateau level.  This presence of TetR is important to prevent crosstalk by LasR activated by C12AHL.
+
</p>
</p>
-
<p>Secondary, we consider the situation that when E.samurai comes to the mimic state. When switching occurs from cautious state to shuriken state, CI is expressed. Not that LacI expression form the Pluxtet hybrid promoter is prohibited, due to the presence of tetR, even in the presence of C12-LasR complex which can bind to the hybrid promoter for its activation. After C12 decomposition, shuriken state should switch back to cautious state.
+
</h2>
 +
<h2>
 +
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;・2. Measurement (Flow cytometer)<br>
 +
<p>・2.1 Measure all samples' OD600.</p>
 +
<p>・2.2 Dilute all samples with 1X PBS to keep OD600 in the range from 0.2 to 0.5.
</p>
</p>
-
<p>Interestingly, CI expression oscillates and converge by C12AHL induction. This is because not only the toggle switch, but also there is a repressilator by combination among TetR, LacI and CI434.  Note that there is difference in CI concentration between the shuriken state and the cautious state.  This difference will be used for the decision making whether E.ninjya releases syuriken or not.
+
<p>・2.3 Take 1 mL (from all samples) into disposal tube (for flow cytometer).
</p>
</p>
-
<p>Then we compared the behavior of the E .Coli in the presence or absence of the crosstalk circumvention circuit. We succeed in confirming that the crosstalk circumvention circuit not only suppresses the crosstalk but also makes the switching faster.  
+
<p> ・2.4 Centrifuge them at 9000 g, 4°C, 1 min. and take their supernatant away.
</p>
</p>
-
<p>The following graph shows the changing of LacI and CI. The solid line stand for the case with CrossTalk prevention circuit, and the dotted line stands for the case without CrossTalk prevention circuit. When there are certain amount of C12 production, LacI is produced in a certain amount in the toggle without CrossTalk prevention circuit, and in contrary, the Crosstalk would not be conspicuous. But in the other circuit which there is CrossTalk prevention circuit, LacI would not be produced and switching to the CI state is conspicuous.
+
<p>・2.5 Suspend all samples with 1 mL 1X PBS.
</p>
</p>
-
<p>For confirming the efficiency of those two toggle switches, we set LacI as the horizontal axis and CI as the vertical axis, then we plot the changing out. We can get the conclusion that the switching is much faster in the circuit with CrossTalk prevention circuit.
+
<p>・2.6 Measure all samples.
 +
</p>
 +
<p>・2.7 Save and organize data.
</p>
</p>
-
 
-
 
</h2>
</h2>
-
<h3>6. application
+
<h3>5. Result of the assay
</h3>
</h3>
-
<h2>
+
<h2><p>From this chart (Fig.3), it turns out the following.  <i>lux/tet</i> hybrid promoter is repressed by TetR in the presence of 3OC6HSL-LuxR complex Similarly, <i>lux/tet</i> hybrid promoter is repressed by TetR in the presence of 3OC12HSL-LasR complex.  In brief, results from E-1) and F-1) are similar to those from E-2) and F-2). Now, therefore, crosstalk circumvention experiment is successful.
-
<p>Our crosstalk circumvention system gives more flexibility to design genetic circuits because this system has a simple network topology composed of two repressor proteins and one repressor and one hybrid promoter.  Along with the topology, one can just choose in any combination of sets of repressor protein and promoter. This system can be used for various genetic circuits that has other crosstalk.  
+
</p>
</p>
</h2>
</h2>
-
<h3>7. Reference
+
<h3>6. Reference
</h3>
</h3>
-
<h2>
+
<h2>1. Gray KM, Passador L (1994) Interchangeability and specificity of components from the quorum-sensing regulatory systems of Vibrio fischeri and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Journal of bacteriology 176(10): 3076–3080.
-
<p>1. Timothy S. Gardner (2000) Construction of a genetic toggle switch in Escherichia coli. Nature 403, 339-342
+
-
</p>
+
-
<p>2. Gray KM (1994) Interchangeability and specificity of components from the quorum-sensing regulatory systems of Vibrio fischeri and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Journal of bacteriology 176(10): 3076–3080.
+
-
</p>
+
-
<p>3. Hideki Kobayashi (2004) Programmable cells: Interfacing natural and engineered gene networks. vol. 101 no. 22 8414–8419
+
-
</p>
+
</h2>
</h2>
 +

Revision as of 17:32, 26 September 2013


Crosstalk Circumvention Assay

1. Introduction

Of course, if you want to avoid crosstalk, you have to search idea for improvement for crosstalk circumvention. However, you must make conditions without affecting system wide, or without changing the basis of system in the idea for improvement. This is because "crosstalk circumvention by changing system wide" is same meaning as saying "crosstalk circumvention only in that circuit". For example, when you want to avoid crosstalk in the circuit on the basis of toggle switch system, you should think that it is nonsense to avoid crosstalk by abandoning toggle switch system. You should think it's nice to avoid crosstalk without abandoning toggle switch system. In short, I hope crosstalk circumvention system is applicable to various circuits. Based on this view, we planned the following idea and experimentation.

2. Summary of the experiment

Our purpose is to check whether lux/tet hybrid promoter would be repressed or not when 3OC12HSL-LasR complex and protein TetR existed. We tried to compare the frequency of crosstalk in the presence or absence of the TetR inhibitor aTc.

We prepared six conditions as follow.
・E-1) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC6HSL induction
・E-2) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC12HSL induction
・E-3) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with DMSO ( no induction)
・F-1) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC6HSL and aTc induction
・F-2) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with 3OC12HSL and aTc induction
・F-3) Culture containing crosstalk circumvention system cell with DMSO and aTc (no induction)
・Positive control and negative control are similarly operated.

3. Results of Prediction

aTc weakens the bonding of TetR and tetO. Therefore, if the GFP expression level of the cells that we added 3OC6HSL and aTc was higher than that of the cells we added only 3OC6HSL, it is proved that lux/tethybrid promoter is repressed by TetR working. Similarly, if the level of GFP expression of the cells we added 3OC12HSL and aTc was higher than that of the cells we added only 3OC12HSL, it is proved that the crosstalk can be suppressed by TetR and the hybrid promoter.

4. Materials and Methods

4-1. Construction

On the previous assay we confirmed crosstalk, which 3OC12HSL-LasR complex activates not only las promoter but also lux promoter too (Gray KM et al., 1994). We came up with idea that crosstalk can be suppressed if lux/tet hybrid promoter is inhibited by protein TetR only when 3OC12HSL-LasR complex is around. We replaced lux promoter with lux/tethybrid promoter. What we have to do in this step is to confirm lux/tet hybrid promoter works correct as a part of the system. Therefore, we tried to make a simple crosstalk circumvention system (Fig.1). Protein LuxR, TetR, and LasR are under a constitutive promoter.

Because of the unexpected restriction enzyme binding site on the regulator plasmid, we had to place protein LuxR and TetR on the regulator plasmid, and lux/tet hybrid promoter, protein GFP and LasR on the reporter plasmid (Fig.2).

To construct the circuit in above figure (Fig.2), we ligated Pcon-RBS-lasR-TT (K553003) and Plux/tet-RBS-GFP-TT (K934025) as the reporter plasmid.  We used Pcon-RBS-luxR-TT-Ptrc-RBS-tetR-TT as the regulator plasmid.
・Reporter: pSB6A1-Pcon-lasR-Plux/tet-GFP / Regulator: pSB3K3-Pc-luxR-Ptrc-tetR (JM2.300)...sample
・pSB6A1-Ptet-GFP (JM2.300)…positive control
・pSB6A1-ΔP-GFP (JM2.300)…negative control

4-2. Strain

   ・JM2.300


4-3. Protocol

   ・1. O/N -> FC -> Induction

・1.1 Prepare overnight culture of each cell (GFP posi, GFP nega, sample) at 37°C for 12 h. (=> O/N)

・1.2 Take 30 microL (from GFP posi, GFP nega, sample) of the overnight culture of inducer cell into LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL+ Kan 30 microg/mL). (=> Fresh Culture)

・1.3 Incubate the flesh culture of cells (GFP posi, GFP nega, sample) until the observed OD600 reaches around 0.50.

・1.4 Take 30 microL each cell suspensions (GFP posi , GFP nega , sample) into
               ・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC6HSL (3 microL),
               ・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC6HSL (3 microL) + 0.05 microg/mL aTc (3 microL),
               ・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC12HSL (3 microL),
               ・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mlL+ Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM 3OC12HSL (3 μL)+ 0.05 mg/mL aTc (3 microL),
               ・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM DMSO (3 microL) and
               ・LB (3 mL) + antibiotics (Amp 50 microg/mL + Kan 30 microg/mL) + 5 microM DMSO (3 microL) + 0.05 mg/mL aTc (3 microL).

・1.5 Incubate all samples (6 samples X 6 kinds of culture = 36 samples) for another 4h at 37°C. (=> Induction)

   ・2. Measurement (Flow cytometer)

・2.1 Measure all samples' OD600.

・2.2 Dilute all samples with 1X PBS to keep OD600 in the range from 0.2 to 0.5.

・2.3 Take 1 mL (from all samples) into disposal tube (for flow cytometer).

 ・2.4 Centrifuge them at 9000 g, 4°C, 1 min. and take their supernatant away.

・2.5 Suspend all samples with 1 mL 1X PBS.

・2.6 Measure all samples.

・2.7 Save and organize data.

5. Result of the assay

From this chart (Fig.3), it turns out the following. lux/tet hybrid promoter is repressed by TetR in the presence of 3OC6HSL-LuxR complex . Similarly, lux/tet hybrid promoter is repressed by TetR in the presence of 3OC12HSL-LasR complex. In brief, results from E-1) and F-1) are similar to those from E-2) and F-2). Now, therefore, crosstalk circumvention experiment is successful.

6. Reference

1. Gray KM, Passador L (1994) Interchangeability and specificity of components from the quorum-sensing regulatory systems of Vibrio fischeri and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Journal of bacteriology 176(10): 3076–3080.