Team:British Columbia/humanpractices/Interviews

From 2013.igem.org

Revision as of 22:41, 27 October 2013 by TonyZhao (Talk | contribs)

iGEM Home

Contents

Academic and Industry Interview Questions

We conducted interviews with both academic and industry professionals. We interviewed professors from academic fields such as Biomedical Ethics, Microbiology, and Immunology along with professionals from the BC Dairy Association (a not-for-profit society promoting milk consumption) to gain a better understanding of the issue of Genetically Modified Organisms in the dairy industry. These interviews helped us develop a public survey for analyzing the general public's opinion on GMOs, and the video below is a summary of our interviews and highlights the many poignant points brought up.

In addition, we also interviewed industry professionals form Olympic Dairy Products Inc. to gain insight into the yogurt production process and to examine how our CRISPR system can be potentially implemented. Interview questions and responses are found below.

Academic and Industry Interview


Basics:

  • Different countries, scientific groups and companies’ definition of GMOs vary. What defines GMOs on a scientific level? What defines GMOs on a legal level?
  • What might be bigger barrier to having a GMO product accepted by the public?

Safety:

  • Are there dangers associated with GMOs? If so, what are these dangers?
  • If GMOs need trial rounds to prove their harmful or harmlessness, would it be worth investing in testing them? Why or why not?

Social Impact and Public Perception:

  • Are there actual harms associated with GMOs or is there a disconnect between public perception and the real science?
  • Is there a legacy or history that influences the perception on GMOs?
  • How would the public view GMO produce as opposed to GMO dairy products? How?
  • How does the idea of Genetically Modified bacteria differ than that of other GMOs (example. Crops) in the public’s opinion?

Ecological and Economical:

  • Is there a capacity for GMO food products to become the most sustainable food source?
  • What role does or will GMOs have in developing food and nutrition issues around the world?
  • How would GMOs affect the industry? For example by minimizing work for farmers etc?
  • Would GMOs help harvesting in more extreme climates and minimize shipping times and costs as a result?

Legal and Moral:

  • Have the policies and regulations kept up with current practices with regards to GMOs?
  • Some argue that we do not currently know enough about GMOs to determine if they are safe and we should therefore assume that they are harmful. Is this a valid argument?
  • Are we ethically obligated to inform the public if and how the products they’re buying was genetically modified?

Would you consider using GMOs if:

  • The price of GMO food products was lower than that of non-GMO food products?
  • GM foods have less ecological impact? (For example not using animals as the meat source)
  • We produced food from waste streams including wood and pulp?
  • GMOs could replace pesticides and antibiotics?
  • Genetically Modified foods tasted better than organic foods?
  • GMOs have medical benefits?